Christmas Day casualties

Earlier this year I accompanied a school group on their trip to Ypres, led by Steve Garnett of Gesta. The first stop on the salient was Essex Farm Cemetery, where John McCrae wrote his famous poem ‘In Flanders Fields’. After an introductory talk by Steve, the students were given some time to look around the cemetery.

For most of them this was the first Commonwealth War Graves Commission cemetery they had visited and they were obviously moved by what they saw. There are over 1,200 soldiers commemorated in Essex Farm, including Valentine Strudwick who was killed aged just 15, only just older than some of the students themselves. Looking at the differences between the headstones they asked a number of pertinent questions – what the different insignia meant, why some of the rows were neat and others weren’t, why some had no name – and so on.

One of the students came up to me and asked why a group of soldiers were all buried close together; on closer examination they were nine men all from the 17th King’s Royal Rifle Corps, their date of death 25th December 1916. I have visited Essex Farm on a number of occasions but had not picked up on this group previously. The men are buried in plots II.W.1 – II.W.9, a row that stands alone at the back of the cemetery to the right of the Stone of Remembrance. I surmised that it was likely they were all killed together in the same incident. I recently came across my picture of the headstones from that trip, and resolved to check what had happened that day.

The graves in Essex Farm cemetery

The 17th Battalion KRRC, was one of the new army service battalions. They had been formed in May 1915 by the British Empire League, a pro-imperialist organisation, and had landed in France on 8th March 1916.

The battalion had spent December training and in reserve interspersed with spells in the front line near the Yser canal. Casualties from shell and rifle fire had already been incurred on the 19th. The four days prior to Christmas were spent in reserve, but on Christmas Day, they headed to the frontline near Brielen, north west of Ypres. Their headquarters was situated at Trois Tours chateau.

The area the 17th KRRC were in on Christmas Day. Trois Tours chateau marked with red box, Essex Farm with red star

The area the 17th KRRC were in on Christmas Day. Trois Tours chateau marked with red box, Essex Farm Advanced Dressing Station with red star

The battalion war diary records ‘Normal routine is carried out, the xmas holiday being postponed until Brigade moves into reserve. The battalion moves up to the front line holding its former position. At 9pm our artillery bombarded the enemy’s trenches. During the hostile retaliation we incurred casualties amounting to nine other ranks killed and five wounded.’

After the unofficial Christmas truce of 1914, efforts were made to ensure that this did not happen again in 1915; Christmas Day 1916 was no different and the CWGC database records that 267 men died on 25th December 1916.

The nine men from the 17th KRRC who were killed that day and are buried at Essex Farm were:

Corporal Arthur William Lake, aged 25. Son of Emily Jane Lake, Of “Roxburgh,” Russell St, Sidmouth, Devon. He is commemorated on Sidmouth war memorial. The epitaph on his headstone at Essex Farm reads “Waiting the Lord’s coming in the clouds for me from heaven”.

Rifleman William George Lampon, aged 19. Born and lived in Peckham.

Rifleman Herbert James Matthews, aged 19. Born in Charlton. Son of Elizabeth and James Matthews, of 28, Adelaide Rd, Brockley. His epitaph reads “There is no death tis but renewing life”.

Rifleman Frederick Henry Scoffield, aged 24. Son of Henry T. G. and Rebecca Scoffield, of 6 Bulwer Rd, Ipswich. His epitaph simply reads “Rest in peace”.

Rifleman Clyde Barton Slator, aged 37. Son of William Barton Slator and Emma Slator, of Greenwich; husband of Ada Louise Slator, of 11, Maidenstone Hill, Greenwich. He had enlisted on 17th June 1916. He is remembered on his parents’ grave in Greenwich cemetery along with his younger brother Gordon, killed in 1918.

Rifleman Charles John Smith. Born in Portsmouth and lived in Stoke Newington.

Still, FrankRifleman Frank Albert Still, aged 35. A Grocer’s assistant from Stoke Newington

(Picture courtesy of Barbara Still, Frank’s granddaughter)

Rifleman John T Tilley. Born in St. Pancras and lived in Camden.

Rifleman George William Wearn. Born in Lea Green, Hants.

Christmas was just another day in the trenches for these men, their deaths statistics of the daily attrition of trench warfare. However the fact that they all died together on Christmas Day and are all buried together adds an element of poignancy, which resonated particularly with some of the students on that trip.

This entry was posted in 1916, Battlefield tours, Research, WW1, Ypres and tagged , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

2 Responses to Christmas Day casualties

  1. Jessica LJ says:

    Just come across this article. My Great Great Grandfather was Clyde Barton Slator. His last diary entry was the day he died 25th December 1916 :

    ‘Thank God for sparing me till now, no more like xmas than ordinary day. Fatigue work pulling down old house till 12-0, thoughts of home , low___ but heart breaking.’

    ‘Oh God, let this war soon end.’

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.